Graphic Novel vs. Narrative Writing

Reading V for Vendetta is definitely a notably different experience than reading a more conventional novel in the form of a narrative, such as The Hours. Through reading a graphic novel, there are many aspects that arise which cannot be reproduced in a more typical writing style. For instance, it is nearly impossible to show facial expressions in writing without the use of graphics. These facial expressions from the characters aided the understanding of the novel by the reader. In addition, a graphic novel can provide the reactions of other characters, in contrast to the traditional narrative. Therefore, the novel of V for Vendetta has the ability to go beyond the text and show the reader more than just the characters’ thoughts and dialogue.

In addition, I found the story of V for Vendetta to be easier to follow than most novels, since I was able to visually see the characters and their emotions in addition to their dialogue and surroundings. However, ironically enough considering the plot and overall theme of this story, I feel as if this graphic novel somehow has more control over the audience and their thought processes. Since the characters and their environments are already designed and illustrated for the reader, little is left for the imagination of the audience. Consequently, I found it a little more difficult to really dive into the novel since I was not able to create my own idea of the characters and their settings.

On the other hand, there are many scenes that were described in this novel in which graphics were necessary in order for the reader to truly comprehend what was happening in the plot, especially since the events were taking place in such a rapid manner. For that reason, I could not see this text being as successful if it were written in any other style.